The real celebrities

When a celebrity is ill, they get lots of attention, but the real
celebrities are the strength of our community. Here's a note from
Gabriele Azhar about her mother, Charlotte Osterburg.

Dear Mr. Holden:

My mother, Charlotte Osterburg, lived in Columbus from 1957 until we
relocated to Florida in October 2006. Mother was very active in the
community and frequently graced the pages of your paper. She retired as
the Programs Officer of the International Training Detachment at Fort
Benning which involved going into the community to interest people in
sponsoring the foreign officers attending various courses, a job she
loved and excelled at. Mother was the first woman Kiwanian in town and
headed the International Relations Committee. She was a Page One judge
in foreign languages as well as participating in many foreign language
events at Columbus State University. During his tenure, Gov. George
Busbee made her an honorary lieutenant colonel for her efforts in
fostering good foreign relations in Columbus. Mother was also a
Gracious Lady of Georgia.

Most important to Mother was the love felt for this country. We
immigrated from Germany in 1957, and there was no prouder American than
Mother.

If you would like to have additional information, please contact me.

Thank you for your consideration.


Gabriele (Gaby) Osterburg Azhar

To our Readers:

As you know, journalists nationwide are in the midst of a struggle to re-make the newspaper business in the wake of profound change. Here are the thoughts of Howard Weaver, Vice President for News at our parent company, The McClatchy Co.

Howard Weaver's Blog

Here's an email request I recently received and my reply:

Mr. (Deleted):

Thank you for your note. Our policy at the newspaper is to disclose race whenever it is part of a substantive description of the person being sought. As a practical matter, this means race plus two other factors, such as approximate age, height and weight. We do not print race when it is the only known factor other than gender.

In other words, we would not print that the alleged criminal was a "white female" (in the Chattahoochee Valley, that description merely narrows the hunt from more than 150,000 women to still more than 80,000 women). On the other hand, if the police are looking for a "white woman, about 5-foot-six and 125 pounds," we would (and do) print this information.

There is one exception to this rule, which serves to get more descriptions into the newspaper. That is this: if the suspect has an "immutable" or unchangeable characteristic such as a visible scar or a tattoo, we print the description, even if we have no other meaningful information beyond race.

Thank you for your concerns about our reporting standards.

Best regards, Ben



From: (Name Deleted)
Sent: Monday, June 30, 2008 7:57 AM
To: Canepa, Valerie - Columbus
Subject: police news


I would like to know why Sara Pauff does not include a better description of the thugs who are mentioned in the local police section today. Gunman, partner invade apartment, and clerk struggles with armed robber! In both cases descriptions are given outside of race. It would be nice to know if we are in danger of these folks and they are white, black, or Hispanic. How are we to look for them and describe them if we don't know there race! Please do a better job at editing your folks, thank you for your time.

Frequent feedback

I get a lot of correspondence in this job. Some very kind and thoughtful, some less so. Most of it is focused on something we didn't get quite right, or on something somebody wants us to put in the paper.

The string of emails that follows illustrates the kind of feedback I get each day, and one typical response. The lesson here, I hope, is the folks at the newspaper are all very busy and we are trying our best to cover a community of more than 300,000 with less than 50 journalists. But if you come at it the right way, you can frequently get exactly what you want. . . Or as my mama always said: "You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar."

Ben Holden
Executive Editor

Changes to newspaper were necessary

I have a great job.

I was never more certain of that fact than when, earlier this month, my wife and I traveled back to Berkeley, Calif., for our 20-year law school reunion.

She works in Columbus as a lawyer. That made sense to everyone.

I work here as the editor of your local newspaper. That made sense to no one.

But here's what they don't get: editing a local newspaper -- even in a time of tough competition from the Internet and in the face of an unforgiving economic downturn -- is a public trust.

You get that. That's why more than 150 of you wrote to us, many expressing concern that your newspaper is shrinking, and therefore our community -- with its great civic pride and justifiably high aspirations -- has taken a step backward. I understand and respect that view.

I don't like reducing the size of the newspaper which has been entrusted to me after 180 years. The choices facing us were difficult, but our Monday/Tuesday cuts were one front-and-back page each day. The actual number of local stories on Page 1 and Local on Monday through Sunday is typically eight or nine. That's about the number we've published each day since September 2004 when I took over as editor.

Also, take a look at your papers from the prior several months for Monday and Tuesday. They average 28 pages. This week we printed 26, or 13 pages front-and-back, rather than 14.

We realize having all the news in two sections on Monday and Tuesday is troubling to many readers, and I have resisted the urge for years to go in this direction because (despite the compelling financial case for doing so) I understood many readers would not like it. But we've said openly that the Monday-Tuesday two-section approach was a necessary evil.

That said, we've heard you and are making adjustments where possible based on your feedback. Many of you told us you enjoyed the Today in History and celebrity birthdays. Starting today, we are reinstating the daily celebrity birthdays feature, and adding back a large portion of the Today in History items on A2.

Also, we are working hard to adjust the weather page to the liking of more of our readers. And while we will undoubtedly not be able to please everyone, we believe we can make some adjustments based on your preferences. If this issue is of great importance to you, contact Jerry Morehouse at 706-320-4422 or jmorehouse@ledger-

enquirer.com by Friday, May 2.

As to editorial pages, many of you have asked about the lineup of columnists for the week. The best news we have to report is that Sunday Voices remains intact, as you see in today's paper. You can continue to enjoy regular columnists George Will, Joe Galloway and Jim Evans in this section. They will be joined by Walter Williams and Froma Harrop. Other columnists have found new homes: Bill O'Reilly will run Monday, and Bill Shipp and Mark Shields will run Saturday.

Also, many of you asked about health inspections. We will be reinstating this feature, which disappeared largely because the state of Georgia changed its reporting system. We hope to have someone trained and a system up-and-running to once again bring you health inspection reports by early summer.

As seven-day-a-week readers of the newspaper have learned, we didn't just take things away. In addition to front-loading news and information into page 1, 2 and 3, we also added a standalone Business section on Friday featuring small business, along with a roundup of our best content offerings on Ledger-Enquirer.com.

We will continue to run a bold, larger-than-standard index on Page 1 to help you find your way around the new format.

Eight out of 10 folks in this community read our paper at least once weekly. We trust them to understand where our country and our local economy stands at present. We believe that when the economy turns, so will all businesses, local and national -- including this one.

Thank you for your continued loyalty to the newspaper, which at the end of the day is a private business managing perhaps the most difficult economy of my adult life. But it is a business with robust growth prospects. In fact, 12 percent more people read our Sunday paper now than in the fall of 2005, and 9 percent more read it daily. And of the 31 newspapers in our company, the Ledger-Enquirer is No. 1 in Sunday home delivery circulation growth.

My mother always told me that nothing worth doing came easy. So I thank you once again, for making this the toughest job I've ever loved.

– Ben Holden

Changes to printed newspaper

Your Ledger-Enquirer looks different today. We have made a number of changes to the paper that are both structural and cosmetic.

First, the newspaper will be organized differently. Local news and opinion will be incorporated into the first section, and sports and business will run in the second section Tuesday through Thursday.

Monday's Major Local Companies package will move to Saturday, and Small Business will move to Friday. Friday's Army Life will move to Tuesday.

The weather map has been moved to A2, and information about lake levels, moon phases and river stages will move to the sports section. Sound Off! has moved from the opinion page to A2.

We will run an expanded index box to help you navigate the paper.

While these changes were made to address rising fuel and newsprint costs, they weren't made lightly. We pulled together a team of editors from all departments to create a more compact paper, and we believe the end result is a paper that is streamlined, better organized, and front-loaded with some of the most popular features.

No changes are planned to our core mission -- to be the best local information resource in the region, both online and in print. We just won nine Georgia Associated Press Awards for excellence, including the prestigious Freedom of Information Award, and our Web site, ledger-enquirer.com, is among the fastest growing sites in our newspaper group.

We welcome your feedback on these changes. Please call me at 706-571-8560.

Ben Holden, executive editor

Death of newspapers greatly exaggerated

If you read the headlines in American newspapers (including this one) you might get the impression from a few marginally informed “experts” that newspapers are on their deathbed. I say hogwash.

Newspapers in general, and the Ledger-Enquirer in particular, remain the dominant sources of local news in their communities and deliver the only mass audience that in any way compares to the historical “Town Square” of yesteryear.

How do we know? Well, because you told us so.

You told us through our March 2008 Market Study, which indicates our daily paper is read by 111,350 folks in this community, a 12 percent increase over the prior two years. The study, based on information approved by the Audit Bureau of Circulation data, also revealed that our Sunday readership had improved even more – to 134,510, or a whopping nine percent jump. (The study period was Fall 2005 vs. Fall 2007).

If we’re dead, nobody told us. Our home delivery circulation continues to grow. Since January, we’re up 1.3% daily and 2.2% Sunday. This despite high gas prices, recession fears and general economic malaise. Things are tough in the news business, to be sure. And eventually I’ll probably write a thing or two about our challenges. But not today. We just got these numbers and it’s time to celebrate.

These figures are a tribute to you, the reader, our remarkably informed and engaged citizenry here in the valley. The numbers also say wonderful things about our staff here at the Ledger-Enquirer.

We are growing due to the efforts of reporters like Mick Walsh, a former U.S. airman who does a great job of covering Ft. Benning. And Dawn Minty, our features editor who oversees coverage areas ranging from religion, to nightlife, to motherhood. Or Mike Haskey, our photo chief, a player-coach who manages a staff, takes photos himself and keeps a great sense of humor all the while.

Speaking of humor, if he were alive, my fellow Missourian, Mark Twain, might have a thing or two to say about all this. If he were me he’d probably scratch his wild patch of hair and wrinkle his unwieldy white mustache and say something like: “News of our death has been greatly exaggerated.”

Ben Holden
Vice President & Executive Editor